Sunday, December 15, 2013

Harvest by Jim Crace - 2013 shortlist

…. rain or shine, the earth abides, the land endures, the soil will persevere for ever and a day.

That quote from Jim Crace's latest book Harvest might lull you into thinking this novel is a homage to the timeless quality oHarvestf the countryside.  It isn't any more than it is a sentimentalised evocation of England's green and pleasant land or even a tribute to the symbiotic relationship between the land and the generations of dwellers for whom the land has provided a means of existence.
Instead it's a deeply thoughtful story that examines the human consequences of a rupture in a  traditional way of life resulting from a pursuit of "Profit, Progress, Enterprise".
The setting is a small rural English community known simply as The Village where life follows the ceaseless cycle of sowing,planting and harvesting  required to eke out even the barest of subsistence living.  The Village exists in a bubble where the regular routine is seldom troubled by anything beyond the ancient oaks and dry stone walls that mark the reaches of the settlement.
Even if the inhabitants are not fully aware of it, this is a way of life that is threatened. As the novel opens, smoke wisps are still rising from the ruins of a stable at the local manor house,  – the result, the villagers believe, of an arson attack. Barely have they recovered from that shock when there is a further signal of a disturbing nature.  New comers have arrived, taking advantage of a law that gives them the right to settle within the village's boundaries as long as they can put up a rudimentary shelter and send up smoke before they are caught. The events become conflated in the minds of the villagers fearful that the year's disastrous harvest will have to stretch even further.
What the villagers do not know is that there is an more profound change on the horizon. The manor lord Master Kent has always taken a paternalistic attitude towards his tenant but now his claim to the estate has been revoked.  The new lord intends to enclose all the fields, turning them from crop growing to the more profitable venture of sheep grazing. The villagers who have tended these fields for generations will be forced out when the land they farm in common is enclosed for sheep. When he arrives to take stock of his new estate complete with his entourage of strong- arm men, aggression, violence and death soon ensue.
Our guide to these events is one Walter Thirsk, an old boyhood friend and former servant of Master Kent. Although he's lived in the village for a dozen years or so after marrying one of the villagers, they still view him as an outsider. Walter has a deep and abiding affection for the fields and oaks around him, viewing them as a form of Eden.  But he has no illusions about the way nature can be inflexible and stern, presenting hardships for those who make their living from the land. He is a realist who knows that the world around him is changing and that it will be to the detriment of his community. For all the new master's talk of a new order "to all our advantages" and the prospect of a life without hard work and where uncertain grain harvests will be swapped for the predictability of sheep farming,  The effects of enclosure for him will be  "to throw a halter around our neck."
Walter sees the economic and human consequences of enclosure. But he also sees it as a rupture of man's connection to his past.
We're used to looking out and seeing what's preceded us, and what will also outlive us. ... Those woods that linked us to eternity will be removed... That grizzled oak which we believe is so old it must have come from Eden to our fields will be felled and routed out. That drystone wall put up before our grandpa's time .... will be brought down entirely ....until there is no trace of it. We'll look across these fields and say, 'This land is so much younger than ourselves."
Crace relates this story in language that at times borders on poetry. There is a close attention to detail - we get many names of hedgerow plants for example which might enable some experts to actually pinpoint the location or even the era. And some wonderfully evocative phrases such as the Turd and Turf,  an area which does double duty as both latrine and burial ground.  Crace has a real feel for the landscape - its shape, its sounds and its smells  - but even more powerfully rendered his is appreciation for man's relation to the land.
My Verdict
A superb novel, one of the best I've read all year. Immediately on finishing it, I wanted to start it all over again. I read it before the judges announced it was not the winner of the 2013 Man Booker Prize. There's no justice in this world!


  1. Hi Karen, whilst this is indeed a fine book, The Luminaries is (in my opinion) a better one. This years list was very strong, in other years both Crace or Ozeki could well have won, they just stumbled across a year when Catton was on the loose. Glad you thoroughly enjoyed Harvest.

  2. I've yet to read The Luminaries, Tony. I've heard so many mixed reviews of it